Author: Genevieve Belcher
Categories: Quality Assurance, Quality Control, Marketing Best Practices
Audience: Independent retailers
Key Takeaways:
Understand the difference between quality assurance and quality control (and why your marketing needs both).
Follow a six-step framework for establishing and maintaining quality standards.
Learn how to assign responsibilities, document processes, and train your team.
Discover what to check across copy, design, technical functionality, and tracking.
Know when and how to refine your standards as tools, teams, and campaigns change.
Whenever I make a mistake in marketing content, it’s usually something minor—something that’s easily overlooked if you don’t have a second set of eyes doing quality control (QC). But just because a mistake is minor (such as a typo) doesn’t mean it isn’t important. When mistakes happen, they stick with me for the rest of the day. But that’s because I’m a perfectionist. Perfection is not realistic, but excellence is attainable.
In the first blog in this series, we discussed why building QC into your marketing processes matters. Now, let’s focus on “the how”: creating standards your team can understand, follow, and improve over time.
At Technology Therapy®️ Group, quality control and attention to detail are core values. We’ve spent years refining our own processes, and we’ve learned that quality doesn’t come from one careful person catching every mistake. It comes from a shared system that makes careful work repeatable.
Quality assurance (QA) and quality control work together, but they serve different roles. QA creates the standards and processes that help prevent mistakes. QC is the review that catches problems before—or soon after—your marketing reaches your audience. You need both. Here is a six-step framework to help your business build them.
“Perfection is not realistic, but excellence is attainable.“
– Genevieve Belcher
Operations Manager, Technology Therapy® Group
TTG’s 6-Step Quality Assurance Framework
Step 1: Assess Your Current State
Before you can define your quality standards, you need to know where you currently stand. Start by pulling your last 5–10 marketing pieces you’ve sent or published—think emails, social posts, and web pages—and review them together as a team.
Review the pieces together and ask:
- What errors do you see?
- Are the same mistakes showing up repeatedly?
- Is important information missing?
- Are there inconsistencies between platforms or team members?
- At what point in the process could someone have caught the issue?
Look for patterns, not people to blame. A recurring typo, broken link, or incorrect date often signals that the process needs a stronger checkpoint. Document what is working too. Your goal is to keep the good habits and close the gaps.
Step 2: Define Your Quality Standards
You can’t implement quality control until you know what your standards actually are and what quality means. “Make sure it looks good” is too subjective. Your standards should be specific enough that two people reviewing the same work would reach similar conclusions.
Work with your team to define and document standards for accuracy, brand consistency, design, functionality, accessibility, testing, and approvals.
This is also the time to clarify ownership. For each type of marketing deliverable, decide:
- Who creates or updates it
- Who reviews it
- Who gives final approval
- Who publishes, schedules, or launches it
- Who trains new team members on the process
When everyone assumes someone else is checking, details slip through. Clear ownership removes that uncertainty.
Step 3: Create Documentation & Checkpoints
Once your standards are defined, put them in writing.
Turn your standards into tools your team can use. Create standard operating procedures (SOPs), checklists, templates, examples, and other step-by-step documentation. These resources reduce guesswork and make it easier for someone to complete a task consistently, even if the person who usually handles it is unavailable.
Then decide exactly where QC happens. Depending on the task, a review could take place before an email is scheduled, before a page is published, before an ad goes live, or immediately after an automation is activated.
Assign a second set of eyes as a non-negotiable checkpoint. The person doing the review should not rely on memory alone; they should use the approved checklist and record that the review happened.
“A second set of eyes should be a non-negotiable checkpoint, not an optional nice-to-have.“
– Genevieve Belcher
Operations Manager, Technology Therapy® Group
Step 4: Train Your Team
A document stored in a folder is not training. Walk team members through the process step by step, explain why each checkpoint matters, and show them what a finished, approved deliverable looks like.
Next, have them complete the process on their own. Double-check their work the first few times and provide specific feedback. If they miss a step, determine whether they need more practice or whether the documentation needs to be clearer.
I recommend using a time-stamped checklist that requires the person completing the task to mark each step. This creates accountability and makes it easier to trace what happened if an error appears later.
A few more best practices worth building into this step:
- Pair newer team members with someone more experienced for their first few reviews, so they have support while they’re still learning the process
- Build in a quick check-in partway through training rather than waiting until the end—it’s much easier to correct course early than fix a habit later
- Revisit training whenever your documentation changes, not just when someone new joins your team
Step 5: Monitor & Reinforce the Process
Once the process is in place, don’t assume it will run perfectly on autopilot. The person accountable for each process should periodically check that team members are following the standards, completing the required reviews, and using the current documentation.
This does not have to feel like policing. A quick spot-check, a review of completed checklists, or a discussion during a team meeting can reveal where people are confused or where shortcuts are starting to creep in.
When someone skips a step, address it promptly and explain the impact. Consistent reinforcement helps QC become part of how your team works, not one more task that disappears when everyone gets busy.
Step 6: Review & Refine
Your quality assurance standards are never final. Platforms change, tools are updated, team members take on new responsibilities, and your business evolves. A checklist that worked last year may now include outdated steps or miss a new risk.
Set a monthly, quarterly, or annual schedule for reviewing documentation and SOPs. The right frequency will depend on the process. An ad-launch checklist may need more frequent updates than a procedure for an annual task.
Beyond your regular review schedule, a few scenarios should automatically trigger a second look:
- After a mistake happens: Conduct a quick, blame-free review of what broke, why it broke, and how to prevent it next time
- When a platform or tool changes: Update steps after switching an email builder, launching a new website theme, or adopting another system
- Before high-volume periods: Review seasonal promotions, holiday automations, staffing responsibilities, and approval timelines before the rush begins
- When onboarding a new team member: Use their questions to identify gaps or unclear instructions in your documentation
Every correction should make the next round stronger. If a mistake happens and the process stays the same, the team has lost an opportunity to improve.
What Should Your Marketing Quality Control Checklist Cover?
Your checklist will vary by channel, campaign, and business. This is not an exhaustive list, but these are some of the most common areas we see businesses overlook:
Copy, Messaging & Basic Details
- Read all copy for spelling, grammar, and punctuation errors
- Confirm prices, promotional codes, dates, deadlines, and offer details
- Verify store hours, addresses, phone numbers, and contact information
- Make sure headlines, callouts, and calls-to-action (CTAs) communicate the intended message
- Confirm the content aligns with the campaign goal, target audience, and approved brand voice
Design, Style & Brand Consistency
- Check that your logo is sharp, correctly sized, and placed according to your brand standards
- Confirm brand colors are accurate and used consistently
- Review fonts and text styling for mismatched sizes, weights, or leftover default formatting
- Make sure images are cropped and sized correctly for each platform
- Confirm buttons and CTAs look clickable and remain consistent in color, shape, and placement
- Check spacing and alignment for overlapping elements, crowded layouts, and awkward headline breaks
- Remove outdated seasonal or promotional graphics from your website, emails, and social channels
Technical Functionality & Display
- Optimize images so they look clear without slowing down the page
- Test website links, email links, buttons, and clickable phone numbers
- Review content on both desktop and mobile devices
- Check how emails and web pages display across the browsers and email clients your audience uses
- Test forms from beginning to end, including the submission, notification, and intended success message
- Confirm automated emails, popups, and other triggered content are current and functioning as intended
Tracking, Testing & Post-Launch Checks
- Complete and save the approved checklist for every campaign
- Send test emails to yourself and at least one other reviewer before the main send
- Monitor live ads during the first few hours after launch
- Confirm tracking links and UTM parameters are set up correctly so you can trust your performance data
- Verify Google Analytics is actively recording data
- Set reminders to test and monitor days or weeks after launch so you can catch anything that breaks later
Build a Process That Makes Excellence Repeatable
Quality control is not about expecting perfection from your team. It is about giving people the standards, training, documentation, and time they need to produce reliable work.
Start with one process that causes frequent frustration or carries a higher risk, such as promotional emails, website updates, or digital ads. Assess what is happening now, define the standard, add a second set of eyes, and document what “done” means. Then refine the process as you learn.
Over time, those individual checkpoints build something bigger: a culture of accountability, consistency, and care. Your audience may never see the checklist behind the work—but they will experience the difference.
Do You Know Where Your Digital Quality Gaps Are?
A second set of expert eyes can uncover broken links, inconsistent experiences, tracking issues, and other problems hiding in your digital presence. Technology Therapy Group’s Digital Audit Program gives you a customized, human-led review and prioritized recommendations, so you know what to fix first and how to move forward with confidence.
